Feith-less

The Washington Times, a vanguard of the liberal anti-war media propaganda machine if there ever was one, savages Doug Feith, one of the Iraq war's architects, and his new memoir War and Decision:
Damn!There is a lot to recommend "War and Decision," Douglas J. Feith's apologia of his 2001-2005 tour as Donald Rumsfeld's under secretary of defense for policy. Few books have chronicled the labyrinthine, cutthroat process of policy-making from the inside in as detailed a manner as has Mr. Feith. Mr. Feith is also a fine writer. But the most important contribution "W&D" makes to the growing body of literature about Afghanistan, Iraq, and the war on terror and why it should be required reading in schools of public service and government was probably inadvertent on Mr. Feith's part.
"W&D" should be widely read so we never again make the mistakes Mr. Feith and his fellow Pentagon, State Department, CIA and White House senior political staffers made during their planning and execution of the Iraq war, or their tunnel vision abandonment of a successful Afghan campaign that has condemned us to near stalemate and a rejuvenated, opium-funded Taliban. It is obvious Mr. Feith is bright. His vacuity about the real world, however, is shocking.
But not unexpected. Mr. Feith's entire professional life has been spent either in the practice of law or the development of public policy. Thus, he comes off as the textbook example of someone to whom process is more important than victory. Mr. Feith loses sight of the real battlefields — the ones on which soldiers die — in favor of the paper wars fought between competing factions of bureaucrats.
For those who don't follow the beltway book tours, Feith has been making the rounds promoting his book at various policy venues throughtout DC. Dr. iRack was at one of these events and was shocked, just shocked (!) at the degree to which Feith managed to blame everybody else (State, CIA, the White House) for the pre/"post" war mistakes (e.g., bad intelligence on Saddam's WMD and AQ links, poor Phase IV planning, failures during the early occupation, etc.) even though, as Undersecretary of Defense for Policy, his Office of Special Plans was in the thick of these decisions. (Dana Milbank over at the Post had a similar reaction after listening to one of Feith's self-delusional, er, I mean, self-promotional book events.) Now that there are warring memoirs (Bremer, Tenet, Feith, etc.), Dr. iRack looks forward to seeing the circular firing squad begin in earnest. Expect many accusations and counter accusation from former Bush administration folks moving forward. Dr. iRack for one wants to see Richard Armitage, the "round mound of diplomacy," square off against Feith in a cage match for the ages!
Tip of the hat to Laura Rozen over at War and Piece for flagging the Washington Times review.
17 comments:
"he comes off as the textbook example of someone to whom process is more important than victory"
Oh damn, did they nail it. That's my entire complaint with lawyers being involved in this at all.
Unless the lawyers name is Andrew Jackson, or Cicero.
And I know honest people do work there..but D.C is a brothel trying to run a charm school. It ain't gonna work.
The fact that Feith places the blame on just about every entity outside of the Office of Special Plans is beyond absurd. (E.g. it was the OSP--not the CIA--that bought into, or at least claimed to believe, Chalabi's claims about Saddam's WMD.)
Fieth and Co get in trouble for selectivity, cherrypicking, etc. It's unfortunate, then, that AM (and iRack) have posted twice about him, and have demonstrated some selectivity of their own. Kissinger called this book "The fullest and most thoughtful statement of the Pentagon thinking prior to and in the first stages of the Iraq war. Even those, as I, who take issue with some of its conclusions will gain a better perspective from reading this book." The author Jean Edward Smith, no fan of Bush, said "Douglas Feith has written a model memoir: fair-minded, objective, and without rancor. The fact that the policy to which he contributed was flawed from the outset in no way diminishes the historical importance of this firsthand account." And Jim Scheshinger wrote that Feith's "judgments are thoughtful—and, for a major player in the process, he is quite objective regarding what went wrong. War and Decision will be a treasure trove for the historians—when the current passions have finally cooled.” Those opinions need to be given some weight, no? Of course there's been criticism--and there's only more to come; this WashTimes guy is a relative nobody--but citing articles by Dana Milbank, who clearly didnt read the book himself, is weak.
There may be a circular firing squad, but they'll all miss.
Just a note - have been a great fan of Abu Muqawama for some time, but am enjoying it less since it has come to be dominated by Dr. iRaq. Charlie and Kip are and always have been charming, smart. and worth hearing from, but personally. this (Iraq and Pakistan) veteran doesn't need or appreciate the new guy's hectoring tone.
Miss Bell,
Sorry if I've been annoying you with too many rants. Abu M and Charlie have been traveling this week, so they asked that the rest of us fill the void.
Just wondering, is it the tone you don't like or the substance?
I don't know, maybe the iRackerman style chest beating like you have "Won" something with the difficulties we are encountering in Iraq. I hear some sort of triumphant laugh after I read your posts.
You may be the next Feith who thinks he is smarter than everyone.
Thanks for asking; I appreciate it. Substance is not a problem. Liked the tip to the CSM piece on Kirkuk. Am interested in hearing your views on the latest what-those-pesky-Iranians-are-doing now briefings.
Just a reservation on tone, really. One of the great things about a blog like this is that many if not most of its readers are pretty plugged in to the policy debates under discussion - and one of the things AM has historically done well is engage those readers with a combination of wry but open-minded curiosity and a "hey, I just thought of this clever and unexpected angle, what do y'all think" approach. Which comes as a breath of fresh air in a foreign policy blogosphere dominated by a "hey, I just went to Syria for the first time, let me school you in how the world works on the basis of what my taxi driver told me about the history of the Alawites."
Having said which, have enjoyed reading your posts, and appreciate your input. Lots of good stuff there.
Sherlock Holmes said...
I don't know, maybe the iRackerman style chest beating like you have "Won" something with the difficulties we are encountering in Iraq. I hear some sort of triumphant laugh after I read your posts.
File under: Smears of 2004.
Meanwhile: ['28-Apr 07:44', 'Sharjah', 'Bagram Air Base .Af', 'Transaviaexport', 'TXC 1701']
Yeah, Transavia just keeps on going.
As resident loonatick allowed for some weird reason to remain: Stylistically, I agree with mrs Bell, dr. Irack. Sarcasm is a stiletto, not a machinegun.;-)
Minor point, the Washington Times didn't savage Douggie, an author of a CIA novel did, and the Times published it. I doubt that we will see any editorial criticizing Mr. Feith or his conduct pre-war and during the war.
Having said that, I quite enjoyed the review. Thanks for the notice.
The tone doesn't help but I think it's also an issue of perceived bias. AM, Charlie and Kip all have biases but these are practitioner based. Dr. iRack comes across as having slightly more political biases, which are less enjoyable to read. There are plenty of other blogs that do politics, I like this one because it's about trying to make the best out of the shit that (all) politicians get us into.
Having said that, I think the good Dr. is a nice late season pick up and should be a valuable contributor for the post-season.
(Note, I can't say anything nice about Ackerman despite his good relationship with this blog. He is very similar to the pundits he enjoys parodying, it's just he's younger and tied in to the COIN zeitgeist. Seems to me that the neocons and their ilk were in the exact same position not that long ago and were equally narrow in their views).
I supppose it won't do any good to ask, but one has to anyway:
Dr. iRack, did you read the book, or just the review?
Washington Times? Is it not an outsourced office service for the Pentagon's apparacheeks who disquise their efforts in post Bush job hunting as oped pieces? Doom will come, hire me and the like. Call me anything but accountable!
runescape money runescape gold tibia item tibia gold runescape accounts tibia money runescape gp buy runescape gold tibia gold tibia item buy runescape money runescape items tibia money
tibia money tibia gold tibia item runescape accounts buy runescape accounts runescape money runescape gold runescape gp runescape power leveling runescape powerleveling cheap rs2 powerleveling runescape equipment buy rs equipment runescape runes cheap rs2 runes runescape logs cheap rs2 logs runescape items buy runescape items runescape quest point rs2 quest point cheap runescape questpoint runescape gold runescape items runescape power leveling runescape money runescape gold buy runescape gold buy runescape money runescape items runescape accounts runescape gp runescape accounts runescape money runescape power leveling runescape powerleveling tibia gold dofus kamas buy dofus kamas wow power leveling wow powerleveling runescape questpoint rs2 questpoint Warcraft PowerLeveling Warcraft Power Leveling World of Warcraft PowerLeveling World of Warcraft Power Leveling Hellgate money Hellgate gold buy runescape logs buy rs2 items cheap runescape items Hellgate London gold Guild Wars Gold buy Guild Wars Gold runescape items rs2 accounts cheap rs2 equipments lotro gold buy lotro gold buy runescape money buy runescape gold buy runescape runes lotro gold buy lotro gold runescape money runescape gold cheap rs2 powerleveling eve isk eve online isk buy runescape power leveling rs2 power leveling tibia gold tibia item runescape accounts Fiesta Silver Fiesta Gold SilkRoad Gold buy SilkRoad Gold Scions of Fate Gold Hellgate Palladium Hellgate London Palladium SOF Gold Age Of Conan Gold AOC Gold ArchLord gold tibia money tibia gold runescape accounts runescape gold cheap rs2 powerleveling buy ArchLord gold DDO Plat Dungeons and Dragons Online Plat
Post a Comment